Autodesk

software, architecture, sustainability, environmental design, architectural science...


Solar Access Analisys

Hi

I have a complex geometry of a building and I am trying to simulate the solar incident solar radiation on the external walls. the problem is that it makes 2 to 3 days to give a result.. Is this logical??

Thank you
Kordou

Lighting Simulation at Summer
Daylight factor and windows interaction

RE: Solar Access Analisys

comment posted by mike :: 26 March 2008 - 11:06pm

wow, 2-3 days of calculating?
i wonder how complex your building is, and/or if it needs to be that complex inside ecotect.

i've done lots of these types of analysis on 'complex' designs, but was able to dumb-down the unnecessary geometry in order to speed up the calculation time.

what type of machine are you running ecotect on?

best,
mike

I'm running a model now

comment posted by chughes :: 28 March 2008 - 11:44pm

I'm running a model now that has been calculating for more than 24 hrs. This is the first time I've used Ecotect for this, but I read all the information I could before hand. The solar radiation is only being calc'd on a few roofs that I dumbed down first. I hope I haven't done something wrong.

Re

comment posted by kordou :: 1 April 2008 - 8:45am

I have simplify a lot the geometry, on only the basic form of the outside geometry and in this run it makes 2 days... I found that if I run an interzonal adjacencies and from there calculate a low shading mask (that takes about 2 hours) then the time is being reduced from 2 days to these 2 hours....

I have a dual core 1.6 Ghz, 2Gb ram..

best,
Kordou

hmm...

comment posted by mike :: 2 April 2008 - 9:37pm

hmm...
i have the best results in both the calc and rendering performance when running the calc on a sub-divided grid from the Surface Subdivide tool and NOT the Analysis grid. (FYI) i usually only use the Analysis grid for interior calcs. don't know if either of you are using the Analysis grid or not, but i was having the worst results using it for exterior Solar Access calcs.

if you haven't already;
- try creating a grid on the face of the geometry in question.

- experiment with the size of the grid in relation to your expected analysis. the smaller the grid the longer the machine will take to make it work.

- keep the grid off of the geometry surface a small amount.

- make sure the normals are facing out.

- for your ref. i've attached an image showing one of my solar radiation studies/analysis with a Surface Subdivide over some complex geometry of a high rise project.

Kordou: i'm almost certain its not a cause of your machine. i've found ecotect is fairly a light load on a standard issue processor, be it AMD/Intel.

hope this helps!
and remember to make a back-up of your file before editing it.

-mike

AttachmentSize
ktc2_04_op_16c_640480.jpg194.31 KB

thnks very helpfull i tried

comment posted by kordou :: 4 April 2008 - 9:06pm

thnks
very helpfull

i tried to use a grid in the inside room and i had to wait 9 hours!!!! to have a result for a specific hour of a day. and when i change the houre another 9 hours....

the subdivition woked fine for the external walls..

best
kodrou



Related websites

Translate This Site

User login